An advance ruling is a written statement by a tax authority on how the law applies to a specific arrangement, given before the arrangement is carried out or before the return is filed. In Gelephu Mindfulness City (GMC), a Special Administrative Region of Bhutan, the ruling system is set out in s. 108 of the Income Tax Act 2025 (Law No. 6 of 2025) and in the Seventh Schedule to that Act. Rulings are made by the Comptroller of Income Tax, the officer appointed under s. 3. Section 108 is enacted, and it commences on a date to be appointed by notification in the Gazette (s. 1(3)(y)).
What a ruling covers
On a proper application, the Comptroller "must make a ruling on how any provision of this Act applies, or would apply" to the applicant and to the arrangement for which the ruling is sought (Seventh Schedule, paragraph 1(1)). A ruling cannot be given on provisions that authorise or require the Comptroller to impose or remit a penalty, inquire into the correctness of a return, prosecute a person or recover a debt. A ruling applies only to the provisions expressly referred to in it and only for the period stated in it.
Under paragraph 8, an application may be made by a person in their own right, by a person "on behalf of a person who is yet to come into legal existence", or by two or more persons jointly.
When the Comptroller may decline or must refuse
Under paragraph 2 the Comptroller may decline where:
- the application would require the Comptroller to determine a question of fact;
- the correctness of the ruling would depend on the making of assumptions;
- the matter is already subject to an objection or appeal;
- the applicant has outstanding debts relating to earlier ruling applications;
- the matter is the subject of a return that has been lodged or is due to be lodged.
Paragraph 3 lists the cases in which a ruling must not be made. They include cases where the Comptroller considers that the person "is not seriously contemplating the arrangement", where the matter concerns tax that is already due and payable or "involves the interpretation of any foreign law", where an assessment for the relevant year has already been made, and where the Comptroller is auditing or investigating the applicant or a similar arrangement for the relevant period. An application should therefore be made before the tax falls due and before any assessment or audit.
What the application must contain
Paragraph 9 sets out the contents of an application. It must:
- identify the applicant;
- "disclose all relevant facts (including the reasons for the arrangement, if applicable) and documents relating to the arrangement";
- state the provision of the Act on which the ruling is sought;
- state the proposition of law relevant to the issues;
- state whether a previous application has been made on the same or a similar arrangement, and its result;
- provide a draft ruling.
The Comptroller may waive the last four requirements where compliance would be unreasonable, but the requirements of identity and full disclosure cannot be waived. Where the correctness of a ruling depends on assumptions, the Comptroller may make the assumptions considered most appropriate, but "may not make assumptions about information which the applicant can provide". An applicant should therefore present the facts as settled and complete. Basnet Law advises on these matters as a law firm. It is not a corporate service provider and does not itself make filings or provide officers.
Fees
The fees are fixed in the second part of the Seventh Schedule and are stated in United States dollars (s. 2AA). They are payable to the "Authority", a body established under written law to administer and collect taxes as agent of the Gelephu Mindfulness City Authority.
- Application fee: $660, which is non-refundable and is paid with the application.
- Further fee: $165 for each hour or part of an hour beyond the first 4 hours of the Comptroller's time, including consultation with the applicant.
- Expedite fee: an optional fee of up to twice the aggregate of the application fee and the further fee, for priority handling.
- Reimbursement: fees for external advice, where the applicant agrees to the Comptroller seeking it, and the Comptroller's costs and reasonable disbursements.
The Authority may waive fees "in exceptional circumstances in its discretion" (s. 108(4)).
When a ruling binds and when it ceases to apply
Where a ruling applies to an arrangement during the period specified, and the person has disclosed in the return that it relied on the ruling, the Comptroller must apply the provision in accordance with the ruling (paragraph 5). Under paragraph 17, a person who has obtained a ruling must disclose in the relevant return the existence of the ruling, whether the person relied on it, and any material changes to the arrangement identified in it.
Under paragraph 7, a ruling does not apply in four cases:
- the arrangement is materially different from the arrangement identified in the ruling;
- there was a material omission or misrepresentation in, or in connection with, the application;
- an assumption made by the Comptroller subsequently proves to be incorrect;
- a condition stipulated in the ruling is not satisfied.
A ruling also ceases to apply from the date on which the relevant provision is repealed or amended in a way that changes how it applies (paragraph 15). The Comptroller may withdraw a ruling at any time by written notice with reasons. The ruling continues to apply for the remainder of its period to an arrangement entered into before the date of withdrawal (paragraph 13).
An application for a ruling does not affect the obligation to file returns or pay tax (paragraph 16). The Comptroller may publish a summary of a ruling only with the applicant's express consent and in a form that does not identify the applicant (paragraph 18).
Common questions
Can a ruling be sought before a GMC company is incorporated?
Paragraph 8 of the Seventh Schedule allows an application "on behalf of a person who is yet to come into legal existence".
Will the Comptroller rule on a question of foreign tax law?
A ruling must not be made where the matter "involves the interpretation of any foreign law", or where it is being dealt with, or should be dealt with, by competent authorities under a double taxation agreement.
Are advance rulings available now?
Section 108 commences on a date to be appointed by Gazette notification (s. 1(3)(y)). The application requirements and fees are already fixed in the Seventh Schedule.