Under the Income Tax Act 2025 of the Gelephu Mindfulness City (GMC), a taxpayer who disputes an assessment first objects to the Comptroller of Income Tax, within 2 months for a company or 30 days for any other person (s. 76(3)). If the Comptroller refuses to amend the assessment, the taxpayer may appeal to the designated officer, and from the designated officer to the Court of First Appeal on questions of law or mixed law and fact where more than USD 200 is at stake (ss. 79 and 81). Penalties range from a 5% late-payment charge (s. 87) to four times the tax undercharged, a fine of up to USD 50,000 and imprisonment of up to 5 years for serious fraudulent evasion (s. 96A). The Act is deemed to have come into operation on 26 December 2024 (s. 1(1)). The penalty and appeal Parts were not deferred under s. 1(3), and the Income Tax Act 2025 (Commencement) Notification 2026, which brought sections 13D, 13F, 13N, 13O, 13OA, 13R, 13T, 13U and 43V into operation on 1 October 2026, does not affect them. This article sets out the civil charges and surcharges, the criminal offences, and the objection and appeal procedure, following the order of the Act.
In short
- Late payment of tax attracts a 5% penalty, followed after 60 days by 1% for each completed month up to a further 12% (s. 87(1)).
- Failure to file a return is an offence with a fine of up to USD 5,000. Failure for 2 years or more adds a penalty of double the tax assessed (s. 94A).
- Incorrect returns attract a penalty equal to the tax undercharged, or double that amount where the error is without reasonable excuse or negligent (s. 95). Wilful evasion attracts treble the tax (s. 96), and serious fraudulent evasion four times the tax (s. 96A).
- Adjustments under the general anti-avoidance rule carry a 50% surcharge (s. 33A), and transfer pricing adjustments a 5% surcharge on the amount adjusted (s. 34E).
- Objections must state precise grounds and be lodged within 2 months (companies) or 30 days (others) from service of the notice of assessment (s. 76(3)).
- An appeal to the designated officer requires a notice of appeal within 30 days of the Comptroller's refusal and a petition of appeal within a further 30 days (s. 79(1)). The burden of proof is on the appellant (s. 80(4)).
- Tax remains payable within one month of the notice of assessment despite any objection or appeal (s. 85(1)).
Civil charges and surcharges
Late payment of assessed tax
If tax is not paid within the period in s. 85, a sum equal to 5% of the tax is added and is collectable as tax (s. 87(1)(a)). The Comptroller must serve a demand note and may enforce payment if it is not paid within one month (s. 87(1)(b)). If the tax is still outstanding 60 days after the 5% penalty, an additional 1% of the outstanding tax is payable for each completed month, capped at 12% (s. 87(1)(c)). These penalties are not treated as tax paid for the purpose of any relief (s. 87(1)(d)), and the Comptroller may remit them for good cause (s. 87(2)).
Employer and payer defaults
An employer that fails to pay over tax deducted from a Bhutanese citizen employee's pay under s. 44B by the 15th day of the second month after payment is liable to a 5% charge, then 1% for each completed month after a further 30 days, up to 15% (s. 44B(7)). An employer that fails to deduct is liable for the amount not deducted (s. 44B(6)). Amounts directed to be deducted from emoluments under s. 91 must be paid over within 10 days, failing which a 5% penalty and monthly penalties of 1% up to 12% apply (s. 91(4)).
Surcharge on anti-avoidance adjustments
Where the Comptroller imposes tax or additional tax under the general anti-avoidance rule in s. 33, a surcharge equal to 50% of that tax is imposed (s. 33A(2)). The surcharge is payable within one month of notice despite any objection or appeal (s. 33A(4)), may be remitted for good cause (s. 33A(7)), and is adjusted if the assessment is varied on objection or appeal (s. 33A(8)).
Surcharge on transfer pricing adjustments
Where the Comptroller increases income, or reduces a deduction or loss, under the arm's length rule in s. 34D, a surcharge of 5% of the amount of the adjustment is recoverable (s. 34E(1)). It is also payable within one month despite any objection or appeal (s. 34E(2)). Transfer pricing is covered in Transfer Pricing and Anti-Avoidance in GMC.
Offences and penalties
General offence
Any contravention of the Act is an offence, except as provided in s. 94A, and where no other penalty is provided the maximum is a fine of USD 5,000, with up to 6 months' imprisonment in default of payment (s. 94(1) and (2)). Failure to comply with a notice is prosecutable only if the notice was served personally or by registered post, except a Gazette notice under s. 68(2) (s. 94(3)).
Failure to make a return
Failing or neglecting without reasonable excuse to comply with s. 62 (returns) or s. 71(1) (partnership returns) is an offence punishable by a fine of up to USD 5,000, with up to 6 months' imprisonment in default (s. 94A(1)). A further penalty of USD 100 a day applies to continued failure after certain repeat convictions for the same year of assessment (s. 94A(2)). Where the failure continues for 2 years or more in respect of a year of assessment, the person is liable to a penalty of double the tax the Comptroller assesses on a best-judgment basis, and to a fine of up to USD 5,000 (s. 94A(3)).
Incorrect returns and information
| Conduct | Penalty | Provision |
|---|---|---|
| Incorrect return or information, or failure to correct a notice of assessment under s. 76(8) | Penalty equal to the tax undercharged | s. 95(1) |
| The same, without reasonable excuse or through negligence | Double the tax undercharged, and a fine up to USD 5,000 or imprisonment up to 3 years or both | s. 95(2) |
| Wilful omission, false statement or false answer with intent to evade tax | Treble the tax undercharged, and a fine up to USD 10,000 or imprisonment up to 3 years or both | s. 96(1) |
| False books or records, or any fraud, art or contrivance, with intent to evade tax | Four times the tax undercharged, and a fine up to USD 50,000 or imprisonment up to 5 years or both | s. 96A(1) |
For both evasion offences, proof of a false statement or entry raises a presumption of intent to evade until the contrary is proved (ss. 96(3) and 96A(3)). Repeat offenders face a minimum term of 6 months' imprisonment: after 3 or more s. 96 convictions, or one s. 96 and one s. 96A conviction (s. 96(2)), and after 2 or more s. 96A convictions (s. 96A(2)).
Information and obstruction offences
Failing without reasonable excuse to comply with a notice under ss. 64, 65, 65A or 65B, or obstructing an officer exercising powers under s. 65B, is punishable by a fine of up to USD 10,000 or imprisonment of up to 12 months or both, with a continuing fine of up to USD 100 a day (s. 65C). A duty of secrecy is generally not a defence (s. 65C(5)). Obstructing the Comptroller or any officer is a separate offence with the same maximum fine and term (s. 98). Failure by an employer to notify the Comptroller of tax deducted under s. 44B is punishable by a penalty of 3 times the tax deducted and a fine of up to USD 10,000 or imprisonment of up to 3 years or both (s. 44B(8)).
Departure without paying
A person who knowingly leaves or attempts to leave GMC in breach of a direction under s. 86 commits an offence and may be arrested without warrant (s. 86(5)).
Compounding, consent and other rules
The Comptroller may compound most of these offences, including those under ss. 94, 94A, 95, 96, 96A and 98 (ss. 94(6), 94A(5), 95(3), 96(4), 96A(4), 98(2) and 101(2)). Prosecutions under ss. 94, 94A, 95, 96 and 96A require the consent of the Comptroller or the Public Prosecutor (s. 101(1)). Penalties do not relieve the person from paying the tax itself (s. 99), and penalties and interest are not treated as tax paid for relief purposes (s. 100(1)). Where fraud or wilful default is involved, an additional assessment may be made at any time (s. 74(2)).
Objections to the Comptroller
Making an objection
A person who disputes an assessment may apply to the Comptroller, by written notice of objection, to review and revise it (s. 76(2)). The application must state precisely the grounds of objection and must be made within 2 months for a company, or 30 days in any other case, from the date of service of the notice of assessment (s. 76(3)). If the assessment amends an earlier assessment, the objection is limited to the amendment (s. 76(2A)). The Comptroller must extend the period where absence, sickness or other reasonable cause prevented a timely objection (s. 76(4)). The periods may be lengthened by rules (s. 76(9)).
Review by the Comptroller
On receiving an objection, the Comptroller may require particulars and documents and may summon and examine witnesses (s. 76(5)). If the taxpayer and the Comptroller agree, the assessment is amended (s. 76(6)(a)). If they do not agree, the Comptroller must give notice of refusal to amend, may revise the assessment to the best of the Comptroller's judgment, and must give notice of the revised assessment (s. 76(6)(b)). That notice of refusal starts the time for appeal.
Appeals to the designated officer
Time limits and form
A person aggrieved by an assessment who has failed to agree with the Comptroller may appeal to the designated officer by lodging a notice of appeal within 30 days after the date of the Comptroller's refusal to amend, and a petition of appeal stating the grounds within 30 days after the notice of appeal was lodged (s. 79(1)). The notice of appeal is deemed withdrawn if no petition follows (s. 79(3)). Late appeals may be permitted for absence, sickness or other reasonable cause if there has been no unreasonable delay (s. 79(11)). The appellant may not rely on grounds not stated in the petition without consent (s. 79(12)). The form, procedure and fees are to be set by regulations (s. 79(13)).
The hearing
The designated officer sends a copy of the petition to the Comptroller, fixes a hearing and gives at least 14 days' notice (s. 80(1)). Both sides may be represented by an advocate and solicitor or an accountant, and by no one else (s. 80(2)). The onus of proving that the assessment is excessive is on the appellant (s. 80(4)). The designated officer may summon witnesses and admit or reject evidence (s. 80(5)), and may require the appellant to furnish security for the tax, failing which the tax becomes immediately payable (s. 80(9)). After the hearing the designated officer may confirm, reduce, increase or annul the assessment (s. 80(10)). Costs are in the designated officer's discretion (s. 80(7)).
Proceedings are heard in private unless either party applies for a public hearing and the designated officer so directs (s. 83(1) and (2)). Decisions may be published without naming the taxpayer, unless the taxpayer consents (s. 83(3) and (4)).
Appeals to the Court of First Appeal
The decision of the designated officer is final except as provided in s. 81 (s. 81(1)). Where the tax payable, the refund, or the notional tax benefit as determined by the designated officer exceeds USD 200, excluding costs, the appellant or the Comptroller may appeal to the Court of First Appeal on a question of law or of mixed law and fact (s. 81(2)). The Act defines the Court of First Appeal as the court first hearing appeals from the designated officer, and procedure follows the applicable court rules (s. 81(2) and (3)). The court may confirm, reduce, increase or annul the assessment (s. 81(4)), and further appeal lies as from the court's original civil jurisdiction (s. 81(5)). The designated officer may also state a case on a question of law for the court's opinion at any time (s. 82).
Finality, payment pending appeal and remission
An assessment becomes final and conclusive if no valid appeal is lodged in time, or once determined on appeal, although the Comptroller may still make an additional assessment under s. 74 that does not reopen a matter decided on appeal (s. 84). Tax remains payable within one month after service of the notice of assessment despite an objection or appeal (s. 85(1)), and the 50% and 5% surcharges are likewise payable notwithstanding a dispute (ss. 33A(4) and 34E(2)). If an appeal succeeds, a refund follows under s. 93, with interest where the Comptroller withholds it pending a further appeal (s. 93(7) and (8)).
Applications for relief for error or mistake under s. 93A are subject to appeal under s. 79, but an appeal is entertained only once USD 250 has been deposited, which is refunded if the appeal is allowed and may be forfeited if it is vexatious or frivolous (s. 93A(5)–(7)). The Comptroller may remit tax on the ground of poverty (s. 92(1)), and the designated officer may remit, reduce or refund tax at discretion, subject to conditions (s. 92(2)).
Many disputes can be avoided by seeking certainty in advance. The site's article Advance Rulings from the GMC Comptroller discusses s. 108, which is one of the provisions listed in s. 1(3) to come into operation on a date appointed by notification and is not among those brought into operation by the 2026 Commencement Notification. The compliance steps that lead to an assessment are covered in Returns, Assessments and Payment of Tax in GMC.
Frequently asked questions
How do I object to a GMC tax assessment?
By written notice of objection to the Comptroller stating precisely the grounds, within 2 months (companies) or 30 days (other persons) from service of the notice of assessment (s. 76(2) and (3)). The Comptroller must extend the time where absence, sickness or other reasonable cause prevented a timely objection (s. 76(4)).
Who hears GMC tax appeals?
Appeals from the Comptroller go to the designated officer under ss. 79 and 80. Further appeal on questions of law or mixed law and fact lies to the Court of First Appeal where more than USD 200 is in issue (s. 81(2)).
What is the deadline for a GMC tax appeal?
A notice of appeal must be lodged within 30 days after the Comptroller's refusal to amend the assessment, and a petition of appeal within 30 days after the notice of appeal (s. 79(1)).
Do I have to pay GMC tax while my objection or appeal is pending?
Yes, Tax is payable within one month after service of the notice of assessment despite any objection or appeal (s. 85(1)). The Comptroller may extend the time on terms (s. 85(2)), and the designated officer may require security pending appeal (s. 80(9)).
What is the penalty for not filing a GMC tax return?
A fine of up to USD 5,000, with up to 6 months' imprisonment in default of payment (s. 94A(1)). If the failure continues for 2 years or more, there is also a penalty of double the tax assessed by the Comptroller (s. 94A(3)).
What are the penalties for tax evasion in GMC?
Wilful evasion carries treble the tax undercharged and a fine of up to USD 10,000 or up to 3 years' imprisonment or both (s. 96). Serious fraudulent evasion carries four times the tax and a fine of up to USD 50,000 or up to 5 years' imprisonment or both (s. 96A).
Who can represent me at a GMC tax appeal hearing?
An advocate and solicitor or an accountant, and no one else (s. 80(2)).
Are GMC tax appeals heard in public?
No, they are heard in private unless the taxpayer or the Comptroller applies for a public hearing and the designated officer so directs (s. 83).
The bottom line
The GMC Income Tax Act 2025 combines graduated civil charges with criminal penalties calibrated to the taxpayer's state of mind, from errors through negligence to wilful and fraudulent evasion. Disputes follow a fixed route from objection to the Comptroller, to the designated officer, and then to the Court of First Appeal on points of law. The time limits are short, the burden of proof is on the taxpayer, and tax is payable while the dispute continues, so objections should be prepared and lodged promptly with the evidence needed to discharge that burden.
This article is general information about the law of the Gelephu Mindfulness City Special Administrative Region as at the date above. It is not legal advice and does not create a lawyer-client relationship.
You may contact Basnet Law at basnet@basnetgmc.com or office@basnetgmc.com for any legal queries related to GMC.
Sources
- Income Tax Act 2025 of the Gelephu Mindfulness City, in particular ss. 1, 33A, 34E, 44B, 65C, 74, 76, 79, 80, 81, 82, 83, 84, 85, 86, 87, 91, 92, 93, 93A, 94, 94A, 95, 96, 96A, 98, 99, 100 and 101
- Income Tax Act 2025 (Commencement) Notification 2026 (S 1/2026), made on 30 September 2026





