A limitation of liability clause in a contract governed by the law of the Gelephu Mindfulness City (GMC) is enforceable to the extent the Unfair Contract Terms Act 2026 allows. Under that Act, a business cannot limit its liability for death or personal injury caused by negligence at all (s. 2(1)). A cap or other limit on liability for other loss caused by negligence, or on liability for breach of contract where the other party deals as consumer or on the business's written standard terms, is valid only if it satisfies the requirement of reasonableness (ss. 2(2), 3). Where the limit is a fixed sum, the court must consider in particular the resources available to the party relying on it and how far it could have insured (s. 11(4)), and the party relying on the clause must prove that it is reasonable (s. 11(5)). The Act was made by the GMC Authority under Article 4(2) of the GMC Royal Charter No. 1 of 2024 and came into operation on 15 June 2026. It does not apply to contracts made, or loss suffered, before that date (s. 30). This article looks specifically at caps, exclusions of categories of loss, time limits and similar limitation devices, and at how the Act treats them. A general account of the Act is in Unfair Contract Terms in GMC: Exclusion Clauses and the Reasonableness Test.
In short
- The Act controls terms that restrict liability as well as terms that exclude it, and treats onerous conditions, restrictions on remedies and restrictions on evidence or procedure as restrictions of liability (s. 13(1)).
- Liability for death or personal injury caused by negligence cannot be limited by any contract term or notice (s. 2(1)).
- Limits on liability for other loss caused by negligence must satisfy the reasonableness requirement (s. 2(2)).
- Limits on liability for breach of contract are controlled where the other party deals as consumer or on the limiting party's written standard terms of business (s. 3).
- Liability for the seller's implied undertakings as to title cannot be limited, and liability for description, quality and fitness cannot be limited against a consumer and must be reasonable against a business buyer (s. 6).
- A term is reasonable if it was fair and reasonable to include having regard to the circumstances known or contemplated when the contract was made (s. 11(1)). For fixed-sum caps, resources and insurance are specific factors (s. 11(4)).
- The controls apply only to business liability (s. 1(3)) and do not apply to international supply contracts (s. 26) or to the contracts listed in the First Schedule.
What counts as a limitation of liability
The Act is expressed in terms of terms that "exclude or restrict" liability. A cap on damages, an exclusion of indirect or consequential loss, a shortened period for bringing claims, or a requirement to give notice of a claim within a fixed time all restrict liability in one way or another. Section 13(1) confirms how widely the controls reach. To the extent the Act prevents the exclusion or restriction of a liability, it also prevents:
- making the liability or its enforcement subject to restrictive or onerous conditions;
- excluding or restricting any right or remedy in respect of the liability, or subjecting a person to any prejudice for pursuing such a right or remedy; and
- excluding or restricting rules of evidence or procedure.
For ss. 2 and 5 to 7, the controls also extend to terms and notices that exclude or restrict the underlying obligation or duty itself (s. 13(1)). A clause drafted to say that a party owes no duty in a particular respect, instead of saying that it is not liable, can therefore be caught. An agreement in writing to refer present or future disputes to arbitration is not treated as excluding or restricting liability (s. 13(2)).
It is immaterial whether the breach was inadvertent or intentional, or whether the liability is direct or vicarious (s. 1(4)).
Which liabilities the Act covers
Business liability
Sections 2 to 7 apply, in contract and in tort, only to business liability: liability for breach of obligations or duties arising from things done or to be done by a person in the course of a business, whether that person's own business or another's (s. 1(3)). "Business" includes a profession and the activities of any GMCA department or local or public authority (s. 1A). The one exception is s. 6, whose controls on sale of goods and hire-purchase terms apply to liabilities arising under any such contract, business or not (s. 6(4)).
Negligence
"Negligence" means breach of a contractual obligation, express or implied, to take reasonable care or exercise reasonable skill in performing the contract, or breach of a common law duty to take reasonable care or exercise reasonable skill, but not any stricter duty (s. 1(1)).
Limits on liability for negligence: section 2
Death and personal injury
A person cannot, by any contract term or by a notice given to persons generally or to particular persons, exclude or restrict liability for death or personal injury resulting from negligence (s. 2(1)). "Personal injury" includes any disease and any impairment of physical or mental condition (s. 1A). A cap on liability that would apply to personal injury claims caused by negligence is ineffective to that extent, regardless of how reasonable the amount may seem.
Other loss or damage
For other loss or damage, such as property damage or economic loss, a person can exclude or restrict liability for negligence only in so far as the term or notice satisfies the requirement of reasonableness (s. 2(2)). A person's agreement to or awareness of such a term is not of itself to be taken as voluntary acceptance of the risk (s. 2(3)).
Limits on liability for breach of contract: section 3
Section 3 applies between contracting parties where one of them deals as consumer, or deals on the other's written standard terms of business (s. 3(1)). As against that party, the other cannot by any contract term, except in so far as the term satisfies the requirement of reasonableness (s. 3(2)):
- when itself in breach, exclude or restrict any liability for the breach;
- claim to be entitled to render a contractual performance substantially different from what was reasonably expected of it; or
- claim to be entitled to render no performance at all in respect of the whole or part of its obligation.
The practical consequence is that a liability cap in a supplier's standard terms of business must be reasonable, even where the customer is itself a business. A cap in a contract negotiated between businesses on bespoke terms is outside s. 3, although s. 2(2) still applies to the extent the cap covers negligence, and s. 6 or 7 may apply to goods. The Act does not define "written standard terms of business", so whether terms qualify is a question for the court on the facts.
Dealing as consumer
A party deals as consumer if it neither makes the contract in the course of a business nor holds itself out as doing so, the other party does make the contract in the course of a business, and, for contracts for goods, the goods are of a type ordinarily supplied for private use or consumption (s. 12(1)). A buyer at an auction or by competitive tender never deals as consumer (s. 12(2)). The burden of showing that a party does not deal as consumer lies on the person who claims it (s. 12(3)).
Indemnities: section 4
A person dealing as consumer cannot by any contract term be made to indemnify another person, whether a party or not, against liability for negligence or breach of contract, except in so far as the term satisfies the requirement of reasonableness (s. 4(1)). This applies whether the liability is direct or vicarious and whether it is owed to the consumer or to someone else (s. 4(2)). An indemnity can operate as an indirect limit on the indemnified party's liability, which is why the Act treats it alongside exclusion clauses.
Goods: sections 5 to 7
Manufacturers' guarantees
Where goods of a type ordinarily supplied for private use prove defective while in consumer use and cause loss through the negligence of a manufacturer or distributor, liability cannot be excluded or restricted by a term or notice in a guarantee of the goods (s. 5(1)). A guarantee is any written promise or assurance that defects will be made good by replacement, repair, compensation or otherwise (s. 5(2)(b)). The section does not apply between the parties to the contract under which the goods passed (s. 5(3)).
Sale of goods and hire-purchase
Section 6 deals with the terms implied by the Sale of Goods Act 2026 and with equivalent terms in hire-purchase agreements:
| Implied term | Against a consumer | Against a non-consumer |
|---|---|---|
| Title, freedom from encumbrances and quiet possession (Sale of Goods Act 2026, s. 12) | Cannot be excluded or restricted (s. 6(1)) | Cannot be excluded or restricted (s. 6(1)) |
| Correspondence with description or sample, satisfactory quality, fitness for purpose (Sale of Goods Act 2026, ss. 13 to 15) | Cannot be excluded or restricted (s. 6(2)) | Only so far as the term is reasonable (s. 6(3)) |
Section 7 applies similar rules to other contracts under which possession or ownership of goods passes, such as contracts for work and materials or hire. Liability for description, quality and fitness cannot be limited against a consumer, and against others only so far as reasonable (s. 7(2), (3)). Liability under any Act implying terms about title, freedom from encumbrances or quiet possession in certain contracts for the transfer of property in goods cannot be limited (s. 7(3A)), and in other cases liability for the right to transfer ownership or give possession, or for quiet possession, may be limited only so far as reasonable (s. 7(4)).
The Sale of Goods Act 2026 itself allows implied terms to be negatived or varied by express agreement, course of dealing or binding usage, but only subject to the Unfair Contract Terms Act 2026 (Sale of Goods Act 2026, s. 55(1)). The implied terms are set out in The Sale of Goods Act 2026 of the Gelephu Mindfulness City.
The reasonableness test applied to caps
The general test
The requirement of reasonableness for a contract term is that the term shall have been a fair and reasonable one to include, having regard to the circumstances which were, or ought reasonably to have been, known to or in the contemplation of the parties when the contract was made (s. 11(1)). The assessment is made at the date of contracting. Events after that date, including the size of the loss that actually occurs, are not part of the test as the Act frames it.
For a non-contractual notice, the test is whether it is fair and reasonable to allow reliance on it, having regard to all the circumstances when the liability arose or would have arisen (s. 11(3)).
Fixed-sum caps: resources and insurance
Where a person seeks to restrict liability to a specified sum of money by a contract term or notice, the court must have regard in particular to (s. 11(4)):
- the resources the person could expect to have available to meet the liability if it arose; and
- how far it was open to the person to cover itself by insurance.
These factors apply in addition to the Second Schedule guidelines where those are relevant (s. 11(4)). A party relying on a monetary cap should be able to explain how the figure relates to its resources and to the insurance cover that was available to it when the contract was made.
The Second Schedule guidelines
For terms controlled by ss. 6 and 7, regard must be had in particular to the guidelines in the Second Schedule (s. 11(2)). The Schedule itself refers to ss. 6(3), 7(3) and 7(4). The guidelines are:
- the relative strength of the parties' bargaining positions, including alternative means by which the customer's requirements could have been met;
- whether the customer received an inducement to agree to the term, or could have contracted with others without a similar term;
- whether the customer knew or ought reasonably to have known of the existence and extent of the term, having regard to any trade custom and previous course of dealing;
- where the term applies if a condition is not complied with, whether compliance was reasonably practicable when the contract was made; and
- whether the goods were manufactured, processed or adapted to the customer's special order.
Section 11(2) also preserves the court's or arbitrator's power to hold, under any rule of law, that a term purporting to exclude or restrict liability is not a term of the contract at all. Questions of incorporation therefore remain relevant alongside the statutory test.
Burden of proof
It is for those claiming that a contract term or notice satisfies the requirement of reasonableness to show that it does (s. 11(5)). In a dispute, the party relying on the cap must prove it is reasonable. The other party does not have to prove that it is unreasonable.
Termination, affirmation and secondary contracts
A term that has to satisfy the reasonableness requirement may be found to do so and be given effect even though the contract has been terminated by breach or by a party treating it as repudiated (s. 9(1)). Where a party entitled to treat the contract as repudiated affirms it instead, the affirmation does not of itself remove the reasonableness requirement (s. 9(2)).
A person is not bound by a term in one contract that takes away rights arising under another contract, so far as those rights relate to a liability that the Act prevents the other party from excluding or restricting (s. 10). A limit placed in a side agreement or framework agreement is therefore subject to the same controls as one placed in the main contract.
Contracts outside the controls
The First Schedule
Sections 2 to 4 do not extend to contracts of insurance, or to contracts so far as they relate to the creation, transfer or termination of interests in land, intellectual property rights or securities, or to the formation, dissolution or constitution of a company (including a partnership) and the rights and obligations of its members (First Schedule, para. 1). Contracts for marine salvage or towage, charterparties and contracts for carriage of goods by ship or hovercraft are subject to s. 2(1) but otherwise outside ss. 2 to 4 and 7 except in favour of a consumer (para. 2). Section 2(1) and (2) do not extend to a contract of employment except in favour of the employee (para. 4).
International supply contracts
The limits imposed by the Act do not apply to liability under an international supply contract, and the terms of such a contract are not subject to the reasonableness requirement under s. 3 or 4 (s. 26(1), (2)). An international supply contract is a contract for the sale of goods, or under which possession or ownership of goods passes, made by parties whose places of business (or habitual residences) are in different States, where the goods are being or will be carried between States, or the offer and acceptance took place in different States, or the goods are to be delivered to a State other than the one where those acts were done (s. 26(3), (4)). For cross-border trade in goods through GMC, liability caps in such contracts are therefore governed by the parties' agreement.
Choice of law
Where GMC law is the proper law of a contract only because the parties chose it, and the contract would otherwise be governed by the law of a country outside GMC, ss. 2 to 7 do not operate as part of that law (s. 27(1)). In the other direction, the Act applies despite a term choosing a foreign law where the term appears to have been imposed wholly or mainly to evade the Act, or where a consumer habitually resident in GMC took the essential steps for making the contract in GMC (s. 27(2)).
Terms authorised by law
Nothing in the Act affects a contractual provision authorised or required by an enactment, or made to comply with an international agreement to which GMC is a party, provided it is no more restrictive than the agreement contemplates (s. 29(1)). A term incorporated or approved by a competent authority acting under a statutory function is treated as reasonable, unless the authority is itself a party to the contract (s. 29(2)).
Points for drafting and review
The provisions above suggest a number of practical points for anyone preparing or reviewing a limitation clause under GMC law:
- carve out death and personal injury caused by negligence expressly, since a limit on that liability has no effect (s. 2(1));
- identify whether the contract is on one party's written standard terms or with a consumer, since that brings s. 3 into play;
- record the basis for any monetary cap, including the limiting party's resources and the insurance available to it, given s. 11(4) and the burden in s. 11(5);
- check the cap against the implied terms in sale of goods contracts, since the title term cannot be limited at all (s. 6(1));
- consider whether the contract is an international supply contract or within the First Schedule, where the controls do not apply; and
- apply the same scrutiny to time limits, notice requirements and remedy restrictions, which s. 13(1) treats as restrictions of liability.
Frequently asked questions
Are limitation of liability clauses enforceable in GMC?
Yes, within the limits of the Unfair Contract Terms Act 2026. A limit on liability for death or personal injury caused by negligence is void (s. 2(1)). Limits on other negligence liability, and on breach of contract where the other party is a consumer or contracts on the limiting party's written standard terms, are enforceable only if reasonable (ss. 2(2), 3). Outside those controls, for example in a negotiated contract between businesses not involving negligence, the clause takes effect according to its terms.
Can a business cap its liability for personal injury in GMC?
A business cannot do so where the injury results from negligence. Section 2(1) prevents any contract term or notice from excluding or restricting liability for death or personal injury resulting from negligence. The only exception in the First Schedule is for contracts of employment, where s. 2(1) applies only in favour of the employee.
Who has to prove that a liability cap is reasonable?
The burden lies on the party relying on the cap. Section 11(5) provides that it is for those claiming that a contract term or notice satisfies the requirement of reasonableness to show that it does.
How does a GMC court judge whether a liability cap amount is reasonable?
The term must have been fair and reasonable to include given the circumstances known or contemplated when the contract was made (s. 11(1)). For a fixed-sum cap, the court considers in particular the resources available to the limiting party to meet the liability and how far it could have insured (s. 11(4)). For goods contracts under ss. 6 and 7, the Second Schedule guidelines on bargaining power, inducements, knowledge of the term, practicability of conditions and special orders also apply (s. 11(2)).
Does the Unfair Contract Terms Act apply to contracts between two businesses in GMC?
It applies to them in part. Section 2(2) applies to limits on negligence liability in any business contract. Section 3 applies between businesses where one deals on the other's written standard terms of business. Section 6(3) and 7(3) require limits on quality and fitness terms in goods contracts to be reasonable. International supply contracts are excluded (s. 26).
Is a time limit for bringing claims a limitation of liability under GMC law?
It can be treated as one. Section 13(1) provides that where the Act prevents the exclusion or restriction of a liability, it also prevents making the liability or its enforcement subject to restrictive or onerous conditions and excluding or restricting any right or remedy. A shortened claims period or strict notice requirement may therefore have to satisfy the same controls as a cap.
Does choosing GMC law bring a foreign contract under the Unfair Contract Terms Act?
It does not bring the contract under ss. 2 to 7. Where GMC law applies only because the parties chose it, and the contract would otherwise be governed by the law of another country, those sections do not operate as part of the proper law (s. 27(1)).
Does the Act apply to contracts signed before 15 June 2026?
The Act does not apply to those contracts. It came into operation on 15 June 2026 and nothing in it applies to a contract made, or to liability for loss or damage suffered, before that date (s. 30).
The bottom line
Under the GMC Unfair Contract Terms Act 2026, a limitation of liability clause will not protect a business against negligence claims for death or personal injury, and a cap on other negligence liability, on liability under standard terms or consumer contracts, or on implied quality terms in goods contracts must be shown to be reasonable by the party relying on it. For monetary caps, the limiting party's resources and insurance position at the time of contracting are central. Contracts within the First Schedule, international supply contracts and contracts governed by GMC law only by choice fall outside the main controls. Basnet Law advises on drafting and reviewing limitation clauses in GMC contracts and on disputes about their effect.
This article is general information about the law of the Gelephu Mindfulness City Special Administrative Region as at the date above. It is not legal advice and does not create a lawyer-client relationship.
You may contact Basnet Law at basnet@basnetgmc.com or office@basnetgmc.com for any legal queries related to GMC.
Sources
- Unfair Contract Terms Act 2026 (GMC), made under Article 4(2) of the GMC Royal Charter No. 1 of 2024: ss. 1 to 7, 9 to 13, 26, 27, 29, 30 and the First and Second Schedules
- Sale of Goods Act 2026 (GMC): ss. 12 to 15 and 55




