Retention of Title and Passing of Property under the GMC Sale of Goods Act 2026

A seller of goods in the Gelephu Mindfulness City (GMC) can retain title until it is paid. Under the Sale of Goods Act 2026, property in specific or ascertained goods passes when the parties intend it to pass (s. 17(1)), and a seller may by the terms of the contract reserve the right of disposal until conditions such as payment are fulfilled, in which case property does not pass to the buyer even after the goods have been delivered (s. 19(1)). A retention of title clause is the contractual expression of that right. The Act was made by the GMC Authority under Article 4(2) of the GMC Royal Charter No. 1 of 2024 and came into operation on 15 June 2026, and it applies to contracts of sale made on or after that date (ss. 1(1), 63). This article explains the rules on passing of property, how a reservation of the right of disposal works, the limits on its protection where the buyer resells, and the related rights of an unpaid seller. A general account of the Act is available in The Sale of Goods Act 2026 of the Gelephu Mindfulness City.

In short

  • Property in goods means the general property, or ownership, as distinct from possession (s. 1A(1)). Delivery and ownership can be separated.
  • No property passes in unascertained goods until they are ascertained, except for undivided shares in an identified bulk (ss. 16, 20A).
  • For specific or ascertained goods, property passes when the parties intend, and the five rules in s. 18 apply only where no different intention appears (ss. 17, 18).
  • A seller may reserve the right of disposal until conditions are met, and property then stays with the seller despite delivery to the buyer or a carrier (s. 19(1)).
  • Risk passes with property unless otherwise agreed, so a retention of title clause should also deal with risk (s. 20(1)).
  • A buyer in possession with the seller's consent can give good title to a third party who buys in good faith without notice of the seller's rights (s. 25).
  • Where property has passed and the buyer does not pay, the seller may sue for the price; where it has not, the seller generally sues for damages unless the price is payable on a day certain (ss. 49, 50).
  • The Act does not apply to transactions in the form of a sale that are intended to operate as a mortgage, pledge, charge or other security (s. 62(4)).

Property, possession and the contract of sale

Sale and agreement to sell

A contract of sale of goods is a contract by which the seller transfers or agrees to transfer the property in goods to the buyer for a money consideration called the price (s. 2(1)). Where property is transferred immediately, the contract is a sale. Where the transfer is to take place at a future time or subject to a condition still to be fulfilled, the contract is an agreement to sell (s. 2(4), (5)), and it becomes a sale when the time passes or the condition is fulfilled (s. 2(6)). A contract of sale may be absolute or conditional (s. 2(3)). A sale on retention of title terms is an agreement to sell in this sense: the buyer usually receives the goods at once, but the property is to pass only when the condition of payment is met.

What "property" means

"Property" means the general property in goods, and not merely a special property (s. 1A(1)). "Delivery" means the voluntary transfer of possession (s. 1A(1)). The Act treats the two separately. Possession may pass on delivery while the general property remains with the seller, which is the effect a retention of title clause is designed to achieve.

When property passes

Unascertained goods

Where goods are sold by description and not identified at the time of contracting, no property passes to the buyer unless and until the goods are ascertained (s. 16). This is subject to s. 20A, which allows a buyer who has paid for some or all of a specified quantity of goods forming part of an identified bulk to acquire an undivided share in the bulk and become an owner in common of it (s. 20A(1), (2)). The parties may agree that s. 20A will not apply, or that it will apply only from a later time (s. 20A(2)).

Specific or ascertained goods: intention

Where there is a contract for the sale of specific or ascertained goods, property passes at such time as the parties intend it to pass (s. 17(1)). Their intention is ascertained from the terms of the contract, the conduct of the parties and the circumstances of the case (s. 17(2)). An express clause stating that property is not to pass until payment is a clear statement of intention for this purpose.

The default rules in section 18

Unless a different intention appears, s. 18 sets out five rules for when property passes:

RuleSituationWhen property passes
Rule 1Unconditional contract for specific goods in a deliverable stateWhen the contract is made, even if payment or delivery is postponed
Rule 2Specific goods that the seller must do something to in order to put into a deliverable stateWhen that thing is done and the buyer has notice of it
Rule 3Specific goods in a deliverable state that the seller must weigh, measure or test to fix the priceWhen that act is done and the buyer has notice of it
Rule 4Goods delivered on approval or sale or returnWhen the buyer signifies approval or adopts the transaction, or on expiry of the fixed or a reasonable time for return without notice of rejection
Rule 5Unascertained or future goods sold by descriptionWhen goods of that description in a deliverable state are unconditionally appropriated to the contract by one party with the other's assent

Rule 1 is the reason a seller who wishes to keep ownership must say so. Without a contrary intention, property in specific goods in a deliverable state passes when the contract is made, even though the buyer has not yet paid (s. 18, Rule 1). Under Rule 5, delivery of goods to the buyer or to a carrier for transmission to the buyer is treated as unconditional appropriation only where the seller "does not reserve the right of disposal" (s. 18, Rule 5(ii)). Goods are in a deliverable state when they are in such a state that the buyer would be bound to take delivery of them (s. 1A(4)).

Rule 5 also deals with the exhaustion of a bulk. Where a bulk is reduced to the quantity due to a single remaining buyer, the remaining goods are appropriated to that buyer's contract and property passes to it (s. 18, Rule 5(iii), (iv)).

Reservation of the right of disposal

The rule in section 19

Where there is a contract for the sale of specific goods, or goods are later appropriated to the contract, the seller may, by the terms of the contract or of the appropriation, reserve the right of disposal of the goods until certain conditions are fulfilled. In that case, despite delivery of the goods to the buyer or to a carrier or other bailee or custodier for transmission to the buyer, the property does not pass until the conditions imposed by the seller are fulfilled (s. 19(1)).

The section leaves the conditions to the seller. Payment of the price for the goods is the usual condition. The Act does not prescribe a form of words, does not require registration of the reservation, and does not address clauses that extend to other debts or to the proceeds of resale. How such a clause operates depends on its terms, read under s. 17(2), and on the general law preserved by s. 62(2), together with s. 62(4) on security transactions discussed below.

Bills of lading and bills of exchange

Two situations are addressed expressly. Where goods are shipped and the bill of lading makes them deliverable to the order of the seller or its agent, the seller is prima facie taken to reserve the right of disposal (s. 19(2)). Where the seller draws a bill of exchange on the buyer for the price and sends it with the bill of lading to secure acceptance or payment, the buyer must return the bill of lading if it does not honour the bill of exchange, and if it wrongfully retains the bill of lading the property does not pass to it (s. 19(3)).

Risk

Unless otherwise agreed, goods remain at the seller's risk until property is transferred, and once property is transferred they are at the buyer's risk whether or not delivery has been made (s. 20(1)). Where delivery is delayed through the fault of either party, the goods are at that party's risk for any loss that would not otherwise have occurred (s. 20(2)). A seller who retains title while the buyer holds the goods will therefore bear the risk of their loss or damage unless the contract transfers risk to the buyer on delivery. Retention of title clauses commonly do so. The parties' duties as bailee or custodier of each other's goods are unaffected (s. 20(3)).

Limits on the seller's protection

The general rule

Where goods are sold by a person who is not their owner and who does not sell with the owner's authority or consent, the buyer acquires no better title than the seller had, unless the owner is by its conduct precluded from denying the seller's authority (s. 21(1)). This is the rule that protects a seller under a retention of title clause. The Act then sets out exceptions.

Buyer in possession after sale

Where a person who has bought or agreed to buy goods obtains possession of the goods or the documents of title with the seller's consent, a delivery or transfer by that person, or by a mercantile agent acting for it, under any sale, pledge or other disposition to a person who receives them in good faith and without notice of any lien or other right of the original seller, has the same effect as if the person making it were a mercantile agent in possession with the owner's consent (s. 25). A mercantile agent is one with authority in the customary course of business to sell, consign for sale, buy, or raise money on the security of goods (s. 26).

This exception is directly relevant to retention of title. A buyer on retention of title terms has agreed to buy and is in possession with the seller's consent. A sub-buyer who takes in good faith and without notice of the seller's rights may therefore acquire good title despite the clause. "Good faith" means honestly, whether or not negligently (s. 1A(2)).

Other exceptions

  • Voidable title. Where the seller has a voidable title that has not been avoided at the time of sale, a buyer in good faith without notice of the defect acquires good title (s. 23).
  • Seller in possession after sale. Where a seller remains in possession of goods or documents of title after selling them, a delivery or transfer by it to a person receiving them in good faith without notice of the previous sale has the same effect as if expressly authorised by the owner (s. 24).
  • Other enactments and powers of sale. The Act does not affect enactments enabling an apparent owner to dispose of goods as if it were the true owner, or sales under a special common law or statutory power or a court order (s. 21(2)).

Security transactions

The provisions of the Act about contracts of sale do not apply to a transaction in the form of a contract of sale that is intended to operate by way of mortgage, pledge, charge or other security (s. 62(4)). Nothing in the Act affects the enactments relating to bills of sale (s. 62(3)), and the Act's definition of "bill of sale" is broad (s. 1A(1)). Where a clause goes beyond retaining title to the goods sold, for example by attaching to new products or to sums owed under other contracts, the question whether the arrangement remains a sale or operates by way of security may arise under these provisions.

Insolvency

The rules in bankruptcy relating to contracts of sale apply despite anything in the Act (s. 62(1)). A buyer is insolvent for the purposes of the Act if it has ceased to pay its debts in the ordinary course of business or cannot pay its debts as they become due (s. 1A(3)).

The unpaid seller's statutory rights

Alongside any contractual reservation of title, the Act gives an unpaid seller rights against the goods. A seller is unpaid when the whole price has not been paid or tendered, or when a bill of exchange or other negotiable instrument taken as conditional payment has been dishonoured (s. 38(1)).

RightWhen availableSection
Lien or right of retentionWhile the seller is in possession, where the sale was without credit, the credit term has expired, or the buyer is insolventss. 39(1)(a), 41
Stoppage in transitWhere the buyer is insolvent and the goods are in course of transitss. 39(1)(b), 44 to 46
Re-saleWithin the limits in s. 48ss. 39(1)(c), 48
Withholding deliveryWhere property has not passed, co-extensive with lien and stoppages. 39(2)

The lien is lost when the seller delivers to a carrier for transmission to the buyer without reserving the right of disposal, when the buyer lawfully obtains possession, or by waiver (s. 43(1)). A reservation of the right of disposal therefore also preserves the seller's position in transit. The unpaid seller's rights are not affected by a sub-sale by the buyer unless the seller has assented, but where a document of title has been transferred to the buyer and the buyer transfers it to a person taking in good faith and for value, a transfer by way of sale defeats the seller's lien or stoppage (s. 47).

Where the goods are perishable, or the seller gives notice of intention to resell and the buyer does not pay within a reasonable time, the seller may resell and recover damages (s. 48(3)). Where the seller expressly reserves a right of resale on default and resells, the original contract is rescinded without prejudice to a damages claim (s. 48(4)). A buyer from a seller who resells after exercising a lien or stoppage acquires good title as against the original buyer (s. 48(2)).

Retention of title and the action for the price

The seller's remedies depend on whether property has passed. Where property has passed and the buyer wrongfully neglects or refuses to pay, the seller may sue for the price (s. 49(1)). Where the price is payable on a day certain irrespective of delivery, the seller may sue for the price even though property has not passed (s. 49(2)). Otherwise, where the buyer wrongfully neglects or refuses to accept and pay, the seller's claim is for damages for non-acceptance, measured where there is an available market by the difference between the contract price and the market price (s. 50).

A seller who retains title should therefore fix a date for payment that does not depend on delivery if it wishes to preserve an action for the price while it still owns the goods. Interest and special damages may be recovered where the law allows (s. 54).

Title warranties that cannot be excluded

In every contract of sale, other than one where the seller is to transfer only such title as it or a third person may have, there is an implied condition that the seller has the right to sell, or in an agreement to sell will have that right when property is to pass (s. 12(1)). There are also implied warranties of freedom from undisclosed charges or encumbrances and of quiet possession (s. 12(2)). Liability for breach of these obligations cannot be excluded or restricted by any contract term (Unfair Contract Terms Act 2026, s. 6(1)). A seller selling on retention of title terms must therefore have the right to sell when property is due to pass.

Frequently asked questions

Are retention of title clauses valid in GMC?

Yes, the Sale of Goods Act 2026 recognises them. A seller may by the terms of the contract reserve the right of disposal until conditions are fulfilled, and property then does not pass to the buyer despite delivery (s. 19(1)). Property in specific or ascertained goods passes when the parties intend, judged from the contract terms, conduct and circumstances (s. 17).

When does ownership of goods pass to the buyer under GMC law?

It passes at the time the parties intend (s. 17(1)). If the contract shows no different intention, s. 18 applies. For an unconditional sale of specific goods in a deliverable state, property passes when the contract is made, even if payment and delivery are postponed (s. 18, Rule 1). For unascertained goods, property cannot pass until the goods are ascertained (s. 16).

Who bears the risk of goods sold on retention of title terms in GMC?

Unless otherwise agreed, risk follows property, so goods remain at the seller's risk until property passes, even if the buyer has them (s. 20(1)). A contract that retains title usually provides for risk to pass to the buyer on delivery.

Can a buyer resell goods before paying if the seller retains title?

A buyer in possession with the seller's consent can pass good title to a sub-buyer who takes in good faith and without notice of the original seller's rights (s. 25). The original seller's protection against third parties is therefore limited once the buyer has possession. The seller retains its contractual and other claims against the buyer.

Does a retention of title clause need to be registered in GMC?

The Sale of Goods Act 2026 contains no registration requirement for a reservation of the right of disposal under s. 19. It does provide that its sale provisions do not apply to transactions intended to operate as a mortgage, pledge, charge or other security, and that the enactments on bills of sale are unaffected (s. 62(3), (4)).

Can a seller who retains title sue for the price in GMC?

A seller who retains title can sue for the price only in some cases. The action for the price is available where property has passed (s. 49(1)) or where the price is payable on a day certain irrespective of delivery (s. 49(2)). Otherwise the seller's claim against a buyer who refuses to accept and pay is for damages for non-acceptance (s. 50).

What rights does an unpaid seller have in GMC without a retention of title clause?

An unpaid seller has a lien on goods in its possession, a right to stop goods in transit if the buyer becomes insolvent, and a limited right of resale (s. 39(1)). Where property has not passed, it may also withhold delivery (s. 39(2)). The lien is lost if the seller delivers to a carrier without reserving the right of disposal (s. 43(1)(a)).

Does the GMC Sale of Goods Act apply to contracts made before 15 June 2026?

The Act applies only to contracts of sale made on or after its commencement on 15 June 2026, and not to those made before (ss. 1(1), 63).

The bottom line

The GMC Sale of Goods Act 2026 allows a seller to keep ownership of goods after delivery by reserving the right of disposal until payment, and the parties' intention governs when property passes. A clause should state clearly when property passes, deal with risk separately, and fix a payment date that preserves the action for the price. Sellers should also bear in mind that a buyer in possession can pass good title to a good-faith sub-buyer under s. 25, and that arrangements operating as security fall outside the Act's sale provisions. Basnet Law advises suppliers and buyers on retention of title terms and on disputes over ownership of goods in GMC.


This article is general information about the law of the Gelephu Mindfulness City Special Administrative Region as at the date above. It is not legal advice and does not create a lawyer-client relationship.

You may contact Basnet Law at basnet@basnetgmc.com or office@basnetgmc.com for any legal queries related to GMC.

Sources

  • Sale of Goods Act 2026 (GMC), made under Article 4(2) of the GMC Royal Charter No. 1 of 2024: ss. 1, 1A, 2, 12, 16 to 21, 23 to 26, 38, 39, 41 to 50, 54, 62 and 63
  • Unfair Contract Terms Act 2026 (GMC): s. 6(1)

Author(s)

Related News

Name *
Phone Number Your phone number is safe with us.
+975
Search
    Legal Advisory Type
    Email *
    Select Your Subject
    Regulatory Advisory
    GMC Investment and Entity Formation
    IP Filing Services
    Money Recovery
    Legal Representations
    Partnerships
    Other Legal Services
    Message/Legal Issues *
    Accept Terms *

    I have read and agree to the Terms and Conditions