Unfair Contract Terms in GMC: Exclusion Clauses and the Reasonableness Test

The Unfair Contract Terms Act 2026 is the Act of the Gelephu Mindfulness City (GMC) that limits how far a business can use contract terms and notices to exclude or restrict liability for negligence and breach of contract. It was made by the GMC Authority under Article 4(2) of the GMC Royal Charter No. 1 of 2024 with the assent of the Druk Gyalpo, and it came into operation on 15 June 2026 (s. 30(1)). It does not apply to contracts made, or to loss or damage suffered, before that date (s. 30(2)). This article explains which terms the Act prohibits outright, which must pass the reasonableness test, how that test works, who deals as a consumer and which contracts fall outside the Act. An earlier article, Commercial Contracts in GMC: The Sale of Goods Act 2026 and the Unfair Contract Terms Act 2026, gives a short overview of this Act together with the Sale of Goods Act 2026.

In short

  • The Act applies mainly to business liability, meaning liability arising from things done in the course of a business (s. 1(3)).
  • Liability for death or personal injury caused by negligence cannot be excluded or restricted by any contract term or notice (s. 2(1)).
  • Exclusion of liability for other loss caused by negligence is effective only so far as the term or notice is reasonable (s. 2(2)).
  • Where one party deals as consumer or on the other's written standard terms, terms excluding liability for breach or allowing substantially different or no performance must be reasonable (s. 3).
  • The seller's implied undertakings as to title under the Sale of Goods Act 2026 can never be excluded, and the undertakings as to description, quality, fitness and sample cannot be excluded against a consumer (s. 6).
  • The party relying on a term must show that it is reasonable, judged at the time the contract was made (s. 11(1) and (5)).
  • Insurance, land, intellectual property, company constitution and securities contracts are outside ss. 2 to 4, and international supply contracts are outside the Act's limits (First Schedule, para. 1; s. 26).

Scope of the Act

Business liability

In both contract and tort, ss. 2 to 7 apply only to business liability, that is, liability for breach of obligations or duties arising from things done or to be done by a person in the course of a business, whether his own or another's (s. 1(3)). The exception is s. 6, which also covers liabilities under any contract of sale of goods or hire-purchase agreement, including private sales (ss. 1(3) and 6(4)). "Business" includes a profession and the activities of any GMCA department or local or public authority (s. 1A).

It does not matter whether the breach was inadvertent or intentional, or whether liability is direct or vicarious (s. 1(4)). Part 1 is subject to Part 3, and the operation of ss. 2 to 4 and 7 is subject to the exceptions in the First Schedule (s. 1(2)).

Key definitions

  • Negligence means breach of a contractual obligation, express or implied, to take reasonable care or exercise reasonable skill in performing the contract, or breach of a common law duty to take reasonable care or exercise reasonable skill, but not any stricter duty (s. 1(1)).
  • Notice includes an announcement, whether or not in writing, and any other communication or pretended communication (s. 1A).
  • Personal injury includes any disease and any impairment of physical or mental condition (s. 1A).
  • Goods has the same meaning as in the Sale of Goods Act 2026 (s. 1A).
  • Court means the judicial body that the Druk Gyalpo designates for the purpose (s. 1A).

Section 1A also defines hire-purchase agreements, conditional sale agreements and hirers, which are relevant to ss. 6 and 7.

Liability for negligence

Section 2 governs attempts to exclude or restrict liability for negligence by a contract term or by a notice given to people generally or to particular people.

  • Liability for death or personal injury resulting from negligence cannot be excluded or restricted at all (s. 2(1)).
  • Liability for other loss or damage resulting from negligence can be excluded or restricted only so far as the term or notice satisfies the requirement of reasonableness (s. 2(2)).

A person's agreement to, or awareness of, a term or notice excluding liability for negligence is not of itself to be taken as voluntary acceptance of the risk (s. 2(3)). A sign at business premises, for example, cannot by itself establish that a visitor accepted the risk of injury.

Liability arising in contract

Section 3 applies between contracting parties where one of them deals as consumer or on the other's written standard terms of business (s. 3(1)). As against that party, the other party cannot rely on a contract term to do any of the following, except so far as the term satisfies the requirement of reasonableness (s. 3(2)):

  • exclude or restrict his liability for his own breach of contract;
  • claim to be entitled to render a contractual performance substantially different from that which was reasonably expected of him; or
  • claim to be entitled to render no performance at all for the whole or part of his obligation.

The section therefore reaches beyond plain exclusion clauses to terms that allow a supplier to vary or cancel what it has promised. It protects business customers as well as consumers where the contract is on the supplier's written standard terms.

Indemnity clauses

A person dealing as consumer cannot be made, by a contract term, to indemnify another person, whether a party to the contract or not, against liability for negligence or breach of contract, except so far as the term is reasonable (s. 4(1)). This applies whether the liability is that of the indemnified person directly or vicariously, and whether it is owed to the consumer or to someone else (s. 4(2)).

Liability arising from the sale or supply of goods

Manufacturers' guarantees

For goods of a type ordinarily supplied for private use or consumption, where loss or damage arises from the goods proving defective while in consumer use and results from the negligence of a person concerned in their manufacture or distribution, liability cannot be excluded or restricted by a term or notice in or operating by reference to a guarantee of the goods (s. 5(1)). Goods are in consumer use when a person uses or possesses them otherwise than exclusively for business purposes, and any writing promising that defects will be made good by replacement, repair, compensation or otherwise is a guarantee (s. 5(2)). Section 5 does not apply between the parties to the contract under which possession or ownership of the goods passed (s. 5(3)), whose position is governed by ss. 6 and 7.

Sale and hire-purchase

Section 6 controls the exclusion of the terms implied by the Sale of Goods Act 2026 and of equivalent terms in hire-purchase agreements.

Implied obligationBuyer deals as consumerBuyer does not deal as consumerSection
Title, freedom from encumbrances and quiet possession (Sale of Goods Act 2026, s. 12, and equivalent hire-purchase terms)Cannot be excluded or restrictedCannot be excluded or restricteds. 6(1)
Correspondence with description or sample, satisfactory quality and fitness for purpose (Sale of Goods Act 2026, ss. 13 to 15, and equivalent hire-purchase terms)Cannot be excluded or restrictedCan be excluded or restricted only so far as the term is reasonables. 6(2) and (3)

The implied terms themselves are described in our article on the Sale of Goods Act 2026.

Other contracts under which goods pass

Section 7 applies a similar scheme to contracts under which possession or ownership of goods passes but which are not governed by the law of sale of goods or hire-purchase, such as contracts for work and materials or hire. It controls terms excluding liability for obligations implied by law from the nature of the contract (s. 7(1)).

  • Against a person dealing as consumer, liability for the goods' correspondence with description or sample, or their quality or fitness for purpose, cannot be excluded or restricted (s. 7(2)).
  • Against any other person, that liability can be excluded or restricted only so far as the term is reasonable (s. 7(3)).
  • Liability under any Act implying terms about title, freedom from encumbrances or quiet possession in certain contracts for the transfer of property in goods cannot be excluded or restricted (s. 7(3A)).
  • In other cases, liability for the right to transfer ownership or give possession, or for the assurance of quiet possession, can be excluded or restricted only so far as the term is reasonable (s. 7(4)).

Other provisions about contracts

Effect of termination or affirmation

A term that must satisfy the reasonableness requirement may be found reasonable and given effect even though the contract has been terminated by breach or by a party electing to treat it as repudiated (s. 9(1)). Where a party entitled to treat the contract as repudiated affirms it instead, that does not of itself remove the reasonableness requirement for any term (s. 9(2)).

Secondary contracts

A person is not bound by a term in one contract that prejudices or takes away his rights under another contract, so far as those rights extend to enforcing a liability that Part 1 prevents the other party from excluding or restricting (s. 10). The Act's protection cannot be avoided by placing the exclusion in a separate agreement.

The reasonableness test

The general test

For a contract term, the requirement of reasonableness is that the term was a fair and reasonable one to include, having regard to the circumstances which were, or ought reasonably to have been, known to or in the contemplation of the parties when the contract was made (s. 11(1)). The test is applied as at the date on which the contract was made.

For a notice that does not have contractual effect, the test is whether it is fair and reasonable to allow reliance on it, having regard to all the circumstances when the liability arose or would have arisen (s. 11(3)).

The burden of proof lies on the party claiming that the term or notice is reasonable (s. 11(5)).

The Second Schedule guidelines

In deciding whether a term is reasonable for the purposes of s. 6 or 7, regard is to be had in particular to the matters in the Second Schedule (s. 11(2)). They are, so far as relevant:

  • the relative bargaining strength of the parties, taking into account alternative means by which the customer's requirements could have been met (para. (a));
  • whether the customer received an inducement to agree to the term, or could have entered into a similar contract with others without a similar term (para. (b));
  • whether the customer knew or ought reasonably to have known of the existence and extent of the term, having regard among other things to trade custom and previous dealings (para. (c));
  • where the term applies if a condition is not complied with, whether compliance was reasonably expected to be practicable at the time of the contract (para. (d)); and
  • whether the goods were manufactured, processed or adapted to the customer's special order (para. (e)).

The Schedule is stated to apply to ss. 6 and 7. Section 11(2) also preserves the power of a court or arbitrator to hold, under any rule of law, that a purported exclusion term is not part of the contract at all, for example because it was not properly incorporated.

Limitation to a fixed sum

Where a term or notice seeks to limit liability to a specified sum of money, regard is to be had in particular to the resources the person could expect to have available to meet the liability, and to how far it was open to him to cover himself by insurance (s. 11(4)). A cap set by reference to available insurance cover is therefore more likely to be found reasonable than an arbitrary figure.

Dealing as consumer

A party deals as consumer in relation to another party if he neither makes the contract in the course of a business nor holds himself out as doing so, the other party does make the contract in the course of a business, and, for contracts for goods governed by the law of sale of goods or hire-purchase or by s. 7, the goods are of a type ordinarily supplied for private use or consumption (s. 12(1)). A buyer at an auction or by competitive tender never deals as consumer (s. 12(2)). It is for the party claiming that another does not deal as consumer to prove it (s. 12(3)).

The same definition applies under the Sale of Goods Act 2026, which uses it to decide which buyers may reject goods for slight breaches and which cannot lose the right to examine goods before acceptance (Sale of Goods Act 2026, s. 1A(4A)).

Varieties of exemption clause

The Act applies to terms according to their effect. Where Part 1 prevents the exclusion or restriction of a liability, it also prevents (s. 13(1)):

  • making the liability or its enforcement subject to restrictive or onerous conditions, such as short notification periods;
  • excluding or restricting any right or remedy in respect of the liability, or penalising a person for pursuing such a right or remedy; and
  • excluding or restricting rules of evidence or procedure.

To the same extent, ss. 2 and 5 to 7 also catch terms and notices that exclude or restrict the relevant obligation or duty itself (s. 13(1)). An agreement in writing to submit present or future differences to arbitration is not treated as excluding or restricting liability (s. 13(2)).

Contracts outside the Act

First Schedule exceptions

Sections 2 to 4 do not extend to the following contracts, or to those contracts so far as they relate to the matters listed (First Schedule, para. 1):

  • contracts of insurance, including a contract to pay an annuity on human life;
  • the creation, transfer or termination of an interest in land;
  • the creation, transfer or termination of rights in patents, trade marks, copyright, registered designs, technical or commercial information or other intellectual property;
  • the formation or dissolution of a company (including any body corporate, unincorporated association or partnership), its constitution or the rights and obligations of its corporators or members; and
  • the creation or transfer of securities or of any right or interest in securities.

For marine salvage or towage, charterparties of ships or hovercraft and contracts for carriage of goods by ship or hovercraft, s. 2(1) applies, but otherwise ss. 2 to 4 and 7 apply only in favour of a person dealing as consumer (First Schedule, para. 2). Similar treatment applies to the sea leg of a multimodal carriage contract (para. 3). Section 2(1) and (2) does not extend to a contract of employment except in favour of the employee (para. 4).

International supply contracts

The Act's limits on excluding or restricting liability by contract term do not apply to international supply contracts, and their terms are not subject to the reasonableness requirement under s. 3 or 4 (s. 26(1) and (2)). An international supply contract is a contract of sale of goods, or a contract under which possession or ownership of goods passes, made by parties whose places of business (or, if none, habitual residences) are in different States (s. 26(3)), and where in addition one of the following applies (s. 26(4)):

  • the goods are in the course of carriage, or will be carried, from one State to another when the contract is concluded;
  • the offer and acceptance were made in different States; or
  • the goods are to be delivered to a State other than the one in which the offer and acceptance were made.

Choice of law

Where GMC law is the proper law of a contract only because the parties chose it, and the law of a country outside GMC would otherwise apply, ss. 2 to 7 do not operate as part of the proper law (s. 27(1)). Conversely, the Act applies despite a term choosing a foreign law where the term appears to have been imposed wholly or mainly to evade the Act, or where one party dealt as consumer, was habitually resident in GMC and the essential steps for making the contract were taken there (s. 27(2)).

Sea carriage of passengers and other legislation

For contracts for the carriage by sea of passengers and their luggage, the Act does not prevent exclusion or restriction of liability in the circumstances and to the extent prescribed by order of the designated officer appointed by the Druk Gyalpo (s. 28).

The Act does not affect contractual provisions authorised or required by an enactment, or made to comply with an international agreement to which GMC is a party and not operating more restrictively than the agreement contemplates (s. 29(1)). A term incorporated or approved by, or under a decision of, a competent authority acting under a statutory function is treated as reasonable, unless the authority is itself a party to the contract (s. 29(2)). A competent authority includes any court, arbitrator or arbiter, GMCA department or public authority (s. 29(3)).

Frequently asked questions

When did the GMC Unfair Contract Terms Act 2026 come into force?

The Act came into operation on 15 June 2026 (s. 30(1)). It does not apply to contracts made, or to liability for loss or damage suffered, before that date (s. 30(2)).

Can a business in GMC exclude liability for personal injury?

No. A person cannot by any contract term or notice exclude or restrict liability for death or personal injury resulting from negligence (s. 2(1)). Liability for other loss caused by negligence can be excluded only so far as the term or notice is reasonable (s. 2(2)).

What is the reasonableness test under the GMC Unfair Contract Terms Act?

A contract term is reasonable if it was fair and reasonable to include it in light of the circumstances the parties knew or ought reasonably to have known when the contract was made (s. 11(1)). The party relying on the term must prove it (s. 11(5)). The Second Schedule lists guidelines such as bargaining strength, inducements, knowledge of the term and whether goods were made to special order.

Does the Unfair Contract Terms Act protect businesses as well as consumers?

Yes. Section 3 protects any party contracting on the other party's written standard terms of business, and s. 2 applies to all business liability for negligence. Business buyers of goods are also protected because exclusions of the quality and description terms must be reasonable (ss. 6(3) and 7(3)).

Are limitation of liability caps enforceable in GMC?

A cap on liability is a restriction of liability and, where the Act applies, must satisfy the requirement of reasonableness. In assessing a cap set at a specified sum, regard is had in particular to the resources available to meet the liability and to how far insurance was available (s. 11(4)). A cap cannot restrict liability for death or personal injury caused by negligence (s. 2(1)).

Who counts as a consumer under the GMC Unfair Contract Terms Act?

A party deals as consumer if he does not contract in the course of a business or hold himself out as doing so, the other party does contract in the course of a business, and, for goods contracts, the goods are of a type ordinarily supplied for private use (s. 12(1)). A buyer at auction or by competitive tender is never a consumer (s. 12(2)).

Does the Act apply to international sale of goods contracts?

The Act's limits on exclusion clauses do not apply to international supply contracts as defined in s. 26, which broadly covers sales between parties in different States involving carriage of goods between States, offer and acceptance in different States, or delivery to another State (s. 26).

Does choosing GMC law bring a contract within the Act?

Only in part. If GMC law applies only because the parties chose it and a foreign law would otherwise govern, ss. 2 to 7 do not operate as part of the proper law (s. 27(1)). A choice of foreign law will not displace the Act where it was imposed mainly to evade the Act or where a consumer habitually resident in GMC made the contract there (s. 27(2)).

The bottom line

The Unfair Contract Terms Act 2026 sets the boundaries within which GMC businesses can limit their liability by contract or notice. Exclusions of liability for negligently caused death or personal injury, and of the seller's title obligations, are ineffective. Most other exclusions, limitation caps and indemnities in standard terms or consumer contracts are effective only if the business can show that they were reasonable when the contract was made. Businesses should review their standard terms, notices and liability caps against ss. 2 to 7 and the Second Schedule guidelines, and should note the exceptions for insurance, land, intellectual property, company, securities and international supply contracts.


This article is general information about the law of the Gelephu Mindfulness City Special Administrative Region as at the date above. It is not legal advice and does not create a lawyer-client relationship.

You may contact Basnet Law at basnet@basnetgmc.com or office@basnetgmc.com for any legal queries related to GMC.

Sources

  • Unfair Contract Terms Act 2026, in particular ss. 1, 1A, 2 to 7, 9 to 13, 26 to 30, the First Schedule and the Second Schedule
  • Sale of Goods Act 2026, ss. 1A(4A) and 12 to 15

Author(s)

Related News

Name *
Phone Number Your phone number is safe with us.
+975
Search
    Legal Advisory Type
    Email *
    Select Your Subject
    Regulatory Advisory
    GMC Investment and Entity Formation
    IP Filing Services
    Money Recovery
    Legal Representations
    Partnerships
    Other Legal Services
    Message/Legal Issues *
    Accept Terms *

    I have read and agree to the Terms and Conditions